Adidas three-stripe trademark ruled invalid by EU court

But the German sporting goods company, whose shares were down 1.3% in a broadly weaker market, said the court’s ruling on Wednesday only affects a particular use of the symbol.The sporting goods industry has seen a rise in trademark and patent disputes as the biggest players try to differentiate their products and justify premium pricing.

High-profile cases have included Adidas clashing with Skechers USA and Nike taking on Puma.The General Court of the European Union said it had upheld a 2016 decision of the European Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) to annul a previous acceptance of the trademark, which Adidas registered in 2014 for clothing, footwear and headgear.Adidas said its trademark consisted of “three parallel equidistant stripes of equal width applied to the product in whichever direction” but this was challenged by Belgium’s Shoe Branding Europe after a decade-long dispute with Adidas.The same EU court had rendered Shoe Branding’s own two-stripe trademark invalid last year, saying the stripes were too similar to those of Adidas.Shoe Branding bought Patrick, which was founded in 1892 and says it is the oldest sports brand in Europe, in 2008. Patrick features two stripes on its shoes and clothing.Adidas needed to show the three stripe mark had acquired a “distinctive character” throughout the EU based on its use so that consumers inherently knew a product was from Adidas and could distinguish it from products of another company.The court said the mark was not a pattern but an “ordinary figurative mark” and it was not relevant to take into account specific uses involving colors.Adidas, which can still appeal to the European Court of Justice, said in a statement the ruling was limited to a “particular execution” of the three-stripe mark and did not impact other protected uses of the trademark in Europe. It was not immediately clear which use Adidas was referring to.“Whilst we are disappointed with the decision, we are further evaluating it and are welcoming the useful guidance that the court will give us for protecting our 3-stripe mark applied to our products in whichever direction in the future,” it said.The court said Adidas had provided evidence related to the mark’s use in five EU countries, but not throughout the bloc.Geert Glas, an intellectual property lawyer at Allen & Overy in Brussels, said the decision seemed to be more based on procedure and that Adidas should be able to produce evidence showing that the three stripes had distinctiveness in Europe.“It’s a setback for Adidas, but it shouldn’t be the end of their three stripes trademark,” Glas said.In other cases involving the big sporting goods players, Nike last year filed a lawsuit accusing German rival Puma of using patented athletic shoe technology without authorization.And a U.S. appeals court said Adidas can protect its Stan Smith tennis shoe against an alleged Skechers knockoff, but that Skechers could sell another mimicking Adidas’ three-stripes.In 2017 a U.S. judge rejected Adidas’ effort to block Skechers from selling athletic sneakers that it said copied its “Springblade” concept. 

Related Posts

Beauty, fashion brands promise to fight plastic pollution with new global commitment

Over 290 organizations signed ‘The New Plastics Economy Global Commitment,’ led by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation in collaboration with UN Environment, on Monday.The document aims to reduce…

France seeks to rekindle love of clearance sales

Retailers are also urging the government to stoke consumer interest at another time of the year with a U.S.-style “Black Friday” bumper discount spell.The government announcement came…

Amazon rolls out AI-generated advertising images

Amazon’s AI engine enables users to personalise a product picture’s background – AmazonAmazon’s AI tool is designed to generate appealing advertising artwork starting from product pictures on a…

Argentine shoe, clothing manufacturers lobby govt over import policies

They said it was difficult to estimate the total number of cases because they are usually settled out of court.In Argentina, importers buy goods and then must…

Amazon workers strike in Germany, Spain on Black Friday

Amazon Germany said around 620 workers were participating in the strikes at its Bad Hersfeld and Rheinberg facilities but the majority of employees were continuing to work…

Italian businesses count heavy cost of coronavirus lockdown

Responding to the spread of the disease in Europe’s worst affected country, the government has banned all non-essential travel and public gatherings until April 3 and closed…